My Father Limited Edition 2011 Short Cigar Review

November 4, 2012 · Posted in Cigar Review, Short Cigar Review 

Wrapper: Hybrid Ecuadorian Habano Criollo   |   Binder: Nicaraguan   |   Filler: Nicaraguan   |   Box of 12: $185.00; Single: $18.50   |   Toro   |   6 ½″ x 52

0/3: While attending an event in Chattanooga in August I got to talking with someone there who told me I had to try this cigar and that I wouldn’t be disappointed even though it costs quite a bit of money. Okay, let’s see.

It is a beautiful cigar. A consistent medium brown color to the wrapper and the feel of said wrapper is oily, soft leather. Like what Pig Pen (of Charlie Brown fame) does to the air whenever he enters the scene this cigar’s aroma was easily discernible even from a couple of feet away and, unlike the case with Mr. Pen, this aroma was a very nice mixture of sweetness and spice.

1/3: I’m greeted with a very strong and distinct pepper that is totally unaffected by any of the other flavors. I think it’s wonderful but those who don’t like pepper probably won’t agree and won’t like the first inch or so of this cigar.

It does change a little after that first inch. The pepper is now more like red pepper flakes. There’s also some leather and sweetness.

2/3: Bright spice enters the fray here. The leather has disappeared. Some fruity flavors have come into the mix. Medium-full bodied cigar.

3/3: A lot of flavor is going on during this final third; spice and fruity sweetness mostly during the first part of this third. After that it morphs into a floral sweetness with some leather creeping back in.

4/3: I am glad that I bought this cigar because the flavors were strong throughout and there was a great deal of evolution in the flavor profile. It was medium-full bodied with a good draw and burn. If you want a special cigar that delivers on everything that matters then you should give this cigar a try.

4.5 out of 5 points – great but not legendary


One Response to “My Father Limited Edition 2011 Short Cigar Review”

  1. Greg on November 4th, 2012 2:04 pm

    Thanks for the cigar review. I’ll have try one if these.

Leave a Reply